Carrie Underwood’s first Thanksgiving as a mom came with one kitchen surprise.

Thanksgiving is this Thursday, and a lot of us are already making grocery lists and hoping the kitchen cooperates. If yours ever hasn’t, you’re in good company. Even Carrie Underwood has been there.

Go back to the fall of 2015. Carrie and her husband, hockey player Mike Fisher, had welcomed their first son, Isaiah, that February. By Thanksgiving he was 8 months old. It was Carrie’s very first Thanksgiving as a mom, and she was home with her baby boy getting ready for the big day.

Life with a new baby means getting creative. On Nov 24, two days before Thanksgiving, Carrie shared a video of herself in the gym using little Isaiah in place of a dumbbell. “Sometimes we just have to make it work!” she wrote. Fans loved it. The post had more than 105,000 likes in two days.

Holidays at Carrie’s house can be a little flexible, too. She’s said her family doesn’t have many “set-in-stone Thanksgiving traditions,” because she’s so often working this time of year. But there’s one she keeps. “I eat a lot every year on Thanksgiving,” she said. Then she added, “I never skip THAT tradition.”

Halloween is another holiday Carrie has had fun with as a mom. In this chat with Taste of Country, she talks about Isaiah’s Halloween outfit.

Carrie talks about Isaiah’s Halloween outfit

So what happened the night before Thanksgiving?

In a lot of homes, Wednesday is baking night. That’s when the pies get made, so Thursday can be all about the big meal and the people around the table. Carrie was in her kitchen too.

On Wednesday, Nov 25, 2015, Carrie posted a photo from her kitchen on Instagram. She’d made a homemade pumpkin pie for the next day’s dinner, and it hadn’t gone well. At all.

Her caption read: “On tomorrow’s menu…pumpkin failure a la mode. #thanksgivingfail #sad #nodessert #smokedetector #ineedanewoven”

Pumpkin failure a la mode. Her hashtags tell the rest of the story, right down to the smoke detector and her wish for a new oven.

It’s hard not to love her for sharing it. A superstar with a new baby and a pie that didn’t make it is about as relatable as it gets the week of Thanksgiving.

A few years later, in 2018, Carrie was asked what she was thankful for. Her second son, Jacob, was on the way.

“I am thankful for, definitely my family. I just have the best. The best kid in the world and another one on the way.”

Family came first on her list: her little boy and the baby on the way.

So if your pie comes out of the oven looking a little rough this Thursday, don’t feel too bad. Carrie Underwood’s first one as a mom never made it to the table either.