Dan + Shay will be at Bridgestone Arena in Nashville on Wednesday, Nov. 18, when the CMA Awards hand out Vocal Duo of the Year. Shay Mooney and Dan Smyers are up against Brooks & Dunn, Brothers Osborne, Muscadine Bloodline and Thelma & James. The show airs at 8 p.m. ET on ABC.
Shay is the voice on hits like “Tequila” and “Speechless.” Away from the stage, the man behind those love songs once got a serious test from the woman he wanted to date.
His wife, Hannah, told the story herself on “Get Real,” the podcast hosted by Caroline Hobby. iHeartCountry wrote about her clip on Aug. 29, 2024.
Before she was Hannah Mooney, she was Hannah Billingsley, a former Miss Arkansas USA. PEOPLE reported that she and Shay had texted on and off for a few years. In March 2015, she asked if his band was ever coming to Arkansas. As luck had it, Dan + Shay were due in her town, Fayetteville, four days later. They met in person at George’s Majestic Lounge on March 11, 2015. That night Shay asked her to be his date to the ACM Awards.
Hannah was in no hurry. She told Arkansas Bride, as quoted by PEOPLE, that she had never pictured herself with a man in the music industry, and that it took her some time to come around.
Then came the weekend Shay made his feelings plain. “I tried to scare him off that weekend because he was like, ‘I really wanna date you,'” Hannah said on the podcast.
Most people in a new romance keep things light and easy. Hannah laid every card on the table. “I don’t care for games,” she told him.
What she said next was a big ask for any young man on the road. “(The) next man I date, I’m gonna marry him,” she told him. “He’s gonna lead our family in Christ. We’re gonna raise our babies to love Jesus.”
She was sure that would end it. “This is what you say to someone to scare them off, right?” she said on “Get Real.” “I think he was 23 at the time, and just starting (his career). And so I was like, ‘this will get rid of him!'”
It didn’t get rid of him at all. “His face lit up,” Hannah said.
She called a friend right after that talk, already sure Shay loved her.
Shay never had any doubts. “From the very first time I saw her, I knew I wanted to marry her,” he told PEOPLE. He proposed in Arkansas on Aug. 9, 2016, while his song “From the Ground Up” played on the radio. PEOPLE reported that he then drove her to a stone chapel, where he had quietly gathered their family and friends, and they married that same night. A bigger wedding followed on the Mooney family property in Arkansas on Oct. 20, 2017.
Hannah has told their love story in full on “Married to the Music,” the podcast hosted by Hanley Riggs. The episode’s own title promises three dresses, a surprise chapel and a house full of boys.
Hannah tells their love story on “Married to the Music”
That house full of boys is real. The family Hannah described that weekend now has four sons. Asher is 9, Ames is 6 and Abram is 3. Baby Aubrey was born in January 2025.
Her road to Shay started on the pageant stage. In this clip posted by Nashville Podcast Network, Hannah looks back on competing for Miss USA.
Hannah looks back on her Miss USA pageant days
On Nov. 18, Shay will be in Nashville hoping to hear Dan + Shay called for Vocal Duo of the Year. In 2015, Hannah expected one serious talk to send him on his way. Eleven years later, four boys will be watching their dad on TV.