Siedah Garrett can still list the outfit. Sitting with comedian Deon Cole for a full episode of his show “Funny Knowing You,” posted on the show’s official YouTube channel this year, she went back to the first time she met Michael Jackson and started with his clothes.
“He had a green corduroy long sleeve shirt, a white crew neck t-shirt underneath, black corduroy pants and those loafers that he wore,” she said.
She has good reason to remember Michael well. Siedah co-wrote “Man in the Mirror” with Glen Ballard, and she’s the voice singing opposite him on “I Just Can’t Stop Loving You.” That duet was the first single from “Bad,” released on July 20, 1987, and it reached No. 1 on the Billboard Hot 100 the week of September 19, 1987. Years later she joined him on the road for the Dangerous World Tour in 1992 and 1993, singing backup and the duet.
At that first meeting, though, none of that had happened yet. There was just Michael in green corduroy, a white T-shirt, black corduroy pants and his loafers. Most of it went together fine. One thing didn’t, and Siedah spotted it right away.
What Siedah noticed
So what was it?
It was his socks. “He had on a gray sock and a green sock,” she told Deon Cole.
One gray, one green, on the biggest star in pop music. Siedah didn’t let it slide. “And I said, ‘Dude, what’s up with your socks?'” Michael had an explanation ready. He told her his room had been dark that morning.
“Sid, look my socks”
Their next meeting was for the song that would put her voice next to his on the radio. “The next time I saw him, we were doing the duet,” she said.
This time Michael was the one who brought up the socks. “He said, ‘Sid, look my socks,'” she said. Sid was his short name for her. Then came his proof: “They match.” Siedah gave him an honest answer: “They match each other, but they don’t match nothing else.”
The first time, she’d been the one asking about his socks. The second time, at the session for a record that would go to No. 1, he was the one showing them off and calling her Sid.
Siedah Garrett tells the sock story on “Funny Knowing You”
This is the full episode on the official channel of Deon Cole’s “Funny Knowing You,” and the video above is set to start at the right spot. Siedah tells the story from about 1:02:33 to 1:03:32: the outfit, the gray and green socks and Michael showing off his matching pair at the duet. It’s a short story, under a minute, and she tells it in order, from his shirt down to his feet, then from the first meeting to the duet.
“I Just Can’t Stop Loving You” debuted on the Hot 100 at No. 37 the week of August 8, 1987, and climbed to the top in its seventh week. Siedah sang it with Michael again on the Dangerous World Tour, years after that first meeting. That day, he’d had on one gray sock and one green one.