Merv Griffin hosted the Jackson 5 in 1974. Michael’s rehearsal question had stunned him.

The Jackson 5 took their seats on “The Merv Griffin Show” in September 1974, just after Michael turned 16. Michael sat with his brothers in a white jacket under his big Afro, and Merv went down the line with questions. He’d already asked the brothers how they got their names. Then he turned to Michael with something that had happened earlier that day, away from the cameras.

“Michael, I didn’t laugh out loud today during rehearsal, but that really stunned me,” Merv told him on the air. Merv hosted a talk show for a living, and the guests on his couch were often stars from the movies. Yet a teenager had asked him one question at rehearsal, and Merv was still thinking about it later that day, with the cameras rolling.

Michael had a reason for asking. He’d just been to the movies, and the picture he’d seen had filled his head with dancers, swimmers and stars from long before he was born. So what did a 16-year-old want to know from a talk show host?

What Michael asked Merv

He’d asked Merv if he had ever heard of Fred Astaire. “Well, he is older than I am,” Merv said, “but he did tap his way into my heart. I guess I’ve seen every movie.”

Then Merv explained where the question came from: “Michael just saw ‘That’s Entertainment!'” MGM had put the film together for the studio’s 50th anniversary, and it premiered in Beverly Hills on May 17, 1974. It’s built from decades of the studio’s own musicals, with Astaire and Gene Kelly among the stars who host it. For a kid who’d been performing since he was small, it was a crash course in the old Hollywood greats.

Astaire wasn’t the only one who’d caught his eye. Merv told the audience Michael had come back talking about “that lady that swims, which is Esther Williams.” What Michael couldn’t work out was the trick behind her famous water numbers: “Did you figure out how she comes up out of the water and her hair is dry?”

Merv asked who else he liked in the film. Michael named Gene Kelly, and “Singin’ in the Rain” came up. Kelly made his list, but Michael had already made up his mind about who was number one, and he said so: “Freddy still looks smoother.” He was 16, on TV, ranking two of Hollywood’s most famous dancers as if he’d been studying them for years.

The Jackson 5 on “The Merv Griffin Show,” September 1974 (fan upload)

This is a fan upload of the full appearance from the YouTube channel Jackson 5Things, not an official release. Merv brings up the rehearsal question at about 10:11, and the talk about Esther Williams, Gene Kelly and Fred Astaire runs until about 11:53.

Merv wasn’t done with Michael after the movies. He wanted to know what was on the teenager’s record player, too. “When you collect records, who do you collect?” he asked. Michael’s answer took in Stevie Wonder, Graham Central Station, Billy Preston, the Mills Brothers and Diana Ross, the woman who’d helped introduce the Jackson 5 to the world.

That list mixed old vocal harmony with brand-new funk, much as his movie talk had mixed a swimming star with two dancing legends. Michael had walked into rehearsal that day with a question about Fred Astaire, and he left the show having told Merv Griffin, on camera, that “Freddy” still looked smoother than Gene Kelly.