Paddy Dunning kept Michael Jackson hidden in Ireland. One day Michael said he’d met Elvis.

Paddy Dunning ran into Michael Jackson one day and could tell straight away that something was off. Michael “looked a bit freaked out,” Paddy remembered in a video for The Guardian. So he asked him. “I said, what’s wrong, Michael?”

Michael’s answer stopped him. “Paddy, I just met my father-in-law Elvis.”

Michael had been married to Elvis Presley’s daughter, Lisa Marie Presley, so Elvis was his former father-in-law. Bumping into him on a quiet estate in the Irish midlands in 2006 was a different thing altogether.

Michael’s secret stay at Grouse Lodge

Paddy owned Grouse Lodge, a residential recording studio in County Westmeath. In 2006 Michael and his three children moved in and stayed for months, and Paddy made sure the outside world didn’t hear about it. “We didn’t tell anybody Michael was here,” he said. “For months and months he was … able to chill out.”

When word did slip out, nobody took it seriously. “Nobody believed it, you know,” Paddy said. If somebody said they’d heard Michael Jackson was there, people would answer, “Yeah, and so was Elvis Presley.”

The Michael that Paddy got to know was easygoing. “He felt really relaxed here,” Paddy said. You could be walking around and “bump into him, say hello.” He found Michael “a very funny guy, very humorous.”

Michael told him why the place felt so different. “Paddy, the first time I’ve ever been in a house with no entourage, with no security basically right outside my front door,” Paddy remembered him saying. So Michael could walk out the door and go for walks up the hill. Now and again he got into town, too. “I brought him into [a] fish and chip shop,” Paddy said.

Sooner or later the press was bound to show up. “Reporters were starting to get in here,” Paddy said, so he moved the family out of Grouse Lodge and up to a guest house on the next estate across the road. “He loved that.”

Who Michael really met

Somewhere in those months, Elvis turned up. Paddy had a secret of his own out on his land. “We’ve got two Elvis Presleys,” Paddy said.

Paddy also owned a wax museum in Dublin. He had “retired” a wax figure of Elvis from it and put it in the woods near the house, IrishCentral reported. That’s the Elvis Michael had just met. “It’s just … it’s Elvis propped up against the tree,” Paddy said.

One wax Elvis might have been enough. There was a second. “The weird thing is there’s two of them,” Paddy said, “so we met him again, you know, in another part.”

IrishCentral told the moment with one more detail in Michael’s line. “Paddy,” he said, “I just met my father-in-law in the woods!”

Paddy Dunning tells the Elvis story in The Guardian’s video

This is The Guardian’s own upload on its official Guardian Music channel, “Michael Jackson’s secret retreat in Ireland.” Paddy starts on the move to the guest house at about 7:24, and the Elvis story is over by 7:58.

Back when the rumors started, people laughed them off with “yeah, and so was Elvis Presley.” Out in Paddy’s woods, there were two of him.