Johnny Carson opened his “Tonight Show” on April 9, 1974, with a big claim. “The Jackson Five are here tonight,” he told viewers. “They’re without a doubt one of the most popular singing groups in the entire world today.” It was the brothers’ first appearance on his show, and Johnny had news to go with it: “on Wednesday they’re going to be doing their first nightclub engagement ever, headlining at the Grand Hotel in Las Vegas for two weeks.”
They sang “Never Can Say Goodbye” first. Then they came over to the couch, and Johnny started counting heads. “The Jackson Five, now I see six,” he said. “Am I losing my mind?”
He wasn’t, one of the brothers assured him. “He’s a new member, Randy.” Then came the line that set up everything later: “Sometimes we slide into Jackson Five and a half.” Randy told Johnny he was 12. The brothers went down the couch with their names, and the last one was “and I’m Michael.” Johnny’s verdict: “Michael. Good, now we got it all straight.”
Michael was 15 that spring, and he’d been at this a long time already. “Michael started when he was four years old,” the brothers told Johnny. Johnny’s reply: “Four? Good heavens.”
There was family news too. Their little sister Janet “always wanted to get into show business,” the brothers said, and she was “all excited and everything” because they’d made her a promise: “we’ll let you be in the Vegas show.”
Then Johnny moved to something every big family knows about. “Do you argue at all over little things?” he asked on “The Tonight Show” in 1974. “How do you resolve it? How do you work it out if you got an argument?”
It turned out they had a system. “Well, each week we have different, you know, leaders,” one of the brothers explained, “and so this week is Jermaine’s.” The week’s leader got to “choose, tell them what to do,” and the others, he said, were “pretty good, they listen.” Nobody kept the job for long. “So next week will be your turn.”
That rotation had one exception, and he was sitting on the same couch. “Randy, you get skipped,” the youngest heard from his brothers, “because you’re only a half so far.”
So the “Jackson Five and a half” joke from a few minutes earlier wasn’t only a joke. Randy had just joined the act, and the leader’s week wasn’t coming his way yet. Johnny had a quip of his own about how that might go: “But when he called rehearsal, he’s inside eating apples or something.”
Watch the Jackson 5’s first “Tonight Show” with Johnny Carson (1974)
This is the full segment on the official Johnny Carson YouTube channel. The couch talk starts at about 3:36, Johnny asks about arguments at about 7:56 and the brothers explain their weekly leader rule at about 8:12, with the Randy line right after.
Going solo came up too, and the answer was short. “We’d rather stay together,” the brothers told him, “trying to stay together as brothers.”
At about 9:30 they were back on their feet for “Dancing Machine.” The nightclub run Johnny had announced at the top of the show, two weeks at the Grand in Las Vegas, was set to start that Wednesday.