Most singers get one shot, John Foster was told no twice. First on Zoom during COVID, then again in person but something in him would not quit. When American Idol called him back in 2024, he walked in with a song for his late best friend and left with every judge leaning in. That moment, “John Foster Was Rejected Twice by Idol Then Producers Called Back and He Blew Everyone Away,” was not about luck, it was about heart.
He sang “Tell That Angel I Love Her,” a song he wrote for Maggie Dunn, and the room fell silent. His voice held so much grief, love and the strength to keep going. It was raw and steady, broken and brave. He did not just sing he shared a piece of his soul. You could hear how much this music mattered to him, that truth carried every note.
John Foster Was Rejected Twice by Idol Then Producers Called Back and He Blew Everyone Away
People felt it deep, it was not just applause, it was tears, quiet nods and looks that said, “We see you.” One fan said, “He is not trying to be anyone else. He is just real” and that is what people held onto. After finishing as runner-up in season 23, he took his story all the way to the Grand Ole Opry stage in 2025. Not as a TV contestant, as an artist.
Even after reaching big milestones, John never forgot where he came from. On May 14, 2025, his hometown in Louisiana celebrated “John Foster Benoit Appreciation Day.” It felt like more than a ceremony, it was a homecoming, a way of saying, “We saw your struggle. We are proud you kept going.”
John Foster Benoit day in Louisiana, 5/14/25, American Idol
That day, he stood with his family and neighbors not as someone more important, but as someone just like them. The people in the crowd were proud. Not just because he was on TV, but because he never changed. He stayed kind and thankful. The kind of person who makes you feel like your own story matters too. His journey showed that winning is not always about a prize. Sometimes it is about the people who believe in you when no one is watching.
John Foster sings from the heart and lives that way too. His music holds real feelings and simple truth. Whether he is honoring a friend or standing on a hometown stage, he brings the same calm strength every time. Follow John Foster on Facebook, Instagram and YouTube the next song might be exactly what you need.