Only one chair turned, but it was the only one that mattered. Manny Costello, a father of two, stepped on stage and sang a country song that stopped Reba McEntire in her tracks. By the time his last note faded, she had tears rolling down her face, whispering that his voice reminded her of George Jones and Merle Haggard.
She called it homesickness, the kind only music can stir. Reba admitted his voice carried her back to where her love for country began, saying it “triggered something that needed to come out.” In a room full of bright lights and cameras, Manny’s song brought silence and stillness, leaving her overwhelmed with gratitude to welcome him to her team.
Father of Two’s Performance Brings Coach Reba to Tears | The Voice Blind Auditions | NBC
Viewers watching from home felt the same wave of emotion. One fan said his tone “sounded like the front porch and the radio on a summer night.” Another wrote, “Reba’s tears told the whole story.” People connected with the way his voice cut through the noise of a competition and simply sounded like a country should.
That moment could have stood on its own, but Reba’s reaction took on a life of its own when her words were shared again. The focus shifted from Manny’s song to her heart, as the short clip spread across timelines. Suddenly, fans everywhere were not only talking about the performance, but about the depth of Reba’s praise for him.
Reba’s High Praise for Manny Costello’s Performance | The Voice Blind Auditions 2025
In this highlight, her voice cracked as she explained how Manny’s sound blessed her and reminded her why she belonged to country music. She welcomed him like family, telling him his performance had opened something inside her. Fans applauded again, saying it was one of the most genuine and emotional moments they had ever seen on the show.
Manny Costello may be new to the spotlight, but his voice already carries the weight of old country legends. He sings with heart, not polish, and that is what made Reba cry and the audience listen. Follow Manny Costello on Facebook, Instagram and YouTube. His journey has only begun, and every note feels like home.