During the American Idol Season 23 finale, Carrie Underwood, a former winner herself, returned not just as a performer but as a first-time judge. As the final votes crowned Jamal Roberts the winner, Carrie offered him five words that carried weight: “Now go do great things.” Simple, strong, and straight from someone who knows exactly what comes next.
Speaking to ExtraTV, Carrie said she saw a little of herself in finalists Jamal, John Foster, and Breanna Nix. Just like her back in 2005, they had raw talent but limited platforms. “This is who the show is for,” she said, highlighting how Idol gives ordinary artists the extraordinary chance to dream big.
Carrie Underwood REVEALS Words to Jamal Roberts After ‘American Idol’ Win! (Exclusive)
Carrie’s presence as a judge brought in strong opinions. Some fans adored her emotional connection and constructive criticism. Others questioned if she had long-term plans on the panel. And now, after her powerful closing message, many are wonderingw as this goodbye?
Carrie also hit the stage with finalist Slater Nalley, performing “I’m Gonna Love You” her duet with Cody Johnson. Mid-performance, Johnson surprised fans by walking out, creating one of the most unforgettable moments of the night.
Cody Johnson Joins Carrie Underwood & Slater Nalley for “I’m Gonna Love You”! – American Idol 2025
Showrunner Megan Michaels Wolflick said confirmation for next season’s panel is “coming soon.” While she praised Carrie’s “constructive feedback” and “nostalgic energy,” she admitted they “never share our hand before the end of the season.”
Carrie Underwood continues to update fans on Instagram, YouTube, TikTok, and Facebook sharing music, mom life, and her ever-evolving role in the country music world.