In Carrie Underwood’s family, the family business was the classroom.
Carrie was born on March 10, 1983, in Checotah, Oklahoma, the youngest of three girls. Her dad, Steve, worked at a paper mill. Marie Claire once described him as “a paper-mill operator.” Her mom, Carole, taught elementary school.
Then there are the big sisters, Shanna and Stephanie. Today they go by Shanna Means and Stephanie Shelton, and they’re a lot older than Carrie. Shanna is 13 years older and Stephanie is 10 years older.
That gap made Carrie’s childhood feel a little different from most. As she put it to Marie Claire, “Technically I have siblings, but they are quite a bit older than me.” She even joked that she has “the only-child syndrome going on.”
Both of her sisters grew up and did what their mom did. They became elementary school teachers too.
So by the time Carrie came along, the family career path was pretty well paved. In 2009 she said it plainly: “Teaching was something that ran in my family.”
Then Carrie went and won “American Idol” in 2005 and became a country superstar.
Her family has stayed right beside her the whole way, even if they’re not the spotlight type. When Marie Claire visited, her parents still lived in the same modest house where she was raised. “My parents are really great people who want nothing to do with any of this,” Carrie said.
The Associated Press had cameras rolling in 2018 when Carrie got her star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame. Her big sisters were there that day, and the clip catches a very emotional Carrie taking it all in.
Carrie Underwood gets emotional at her Hollywood Walk of Fame ceremony
So what does Carrie call herself, the one who went to Nashville instead of the teachers’ lounge?
Carrie told Marie Claire she has a name for it. “I’m the black sheep of the family,” she said.
And then she added a little sparkle. “The black-crystal sheep. Swarovski.”
It’s a joke, and a pretty good one. She’s clearly proud of where she comes from. She just happens to be the one on a stage instead of at the chalkboard.
There’s a second fun piece to this. With sisters that much older, little Carrie was the baby of the house and her big sisters treated her that way. “I was totally a human Barbie doll to them,” she told Marie Claire in 2010, as quoted by People, because “they would dress me and put makeup on me.”
Carrie has said that’s where her love of makeup started. So the girls who grew up to teach other people’s kids were giving their baby sister her very first makeup lessons.
The sisters were front and center when she won “American Idol” in 2005. And in July 2023, Carole and both sisters got matching heart tattoos with Carrie in Las Vegas.