A Grammy nomination is great, but a cookie in your name might be sweeter. Benson Boone wanted the world to respect his special dessert song. His song “Mystical Magical” was an ode to love. But it did not receive a nomination for the 2026 Grammys. This really got people talking about the unusual lyrics.
Instead of being sad, Benson poked fun at the situation. He posted an Instagram Story joking that “moonbeam ice cream” was “pure lyrical genius.” He leaned into the chatter. He showed everyone that you do not have to take yourself so seriously all the time. It was a fun way to handle disappointment.
Benson Boone Trolls Himself After Grammy Nominations Snub | E! News
The song first became a viral meme on TikTok in April. Many fans did not understand the line about the sweet treat. They joked about the lyrics. Benson later admitted his songwriter, Jack LaFrantz, made up the playful line. It started as a placeholder, but Benson decided he really liked it.
While the story behind the song is funny, the song itself has a lot of heart. “Mystical Magical” may not have received a Grammy nod, but it did get him his own “Moonbeam Ice Cream” Crumbl cookie. That silly line he loved so much became the focus. Now, let us look at the song that started it all.
Benson Boone – Mystical Magical (Official Lyric Video)
The lyric video itself shows the words to this playful love song. Benson sings about someone who is hot and cold, dragging him along one minute and kissing him the next. The famous chorus describes a feeling that is sweet and fun, just like “moon beam ice cream”. It shows why he fought to keep the line.
Benson Boone has a style that is full of feeling but also very fun. He is not afraid to be silly, and that makes people connect with him. He shares his journey with a lot of honesty. Follow Benson Boone on Facebook, Instagram, and YouTube. You never know if his next big song will be about ice cream or heartbreak.