Twenty years can feel like a lifetime, but for Carrie Underwood it was the distance between being a nervous farm girl stepping on stage in 2005 and returning in 2025 as a judge on American Idol. After winning season 4, she built one of country music’s strongest careers. Now she sits at the table once held by Simon, Paula, and Randy, but with a different mission: to lift contestants instead of break them down.
Her new role is not just symbolic. Carrie replaced Katy Perry, who left after seven seasons, and joined Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan on the panel. That makes her the first Idol winner to return as a permanent judge. She has been open about wanting to offer guidance with compassion, using her own memories of fear and doubt to give others the kind of encouragement she once needed most.
Your favorite judges are back and class is in session! Idol Across America auditions start this week! Sign up!
Fans have been quick to celebrate this milestone. One person commented that it felt “like Idol finally came full circle.” Another called it “the best decision the show has made in years,” while others pointed out how much weight her words carry because she has lived it. The overwhelming reaction has been gratitude, both for Carrie’s return and for the show honoring its own history.
Carrie’s journey as a judge naturally invites a look back at where it all began. Before stadium tours, Grammys, and platinum albums, there was a shy young woman standing in front of Simon Cowell, Randy Jackson, and Paula Abdul. As part of the IDOL TO ICON series, she recently revisited her first audition, rewatching the tape that started everything and reading pages from her old journal.
Carrie Underwood Watches Her American Idol Audition, Shares Personal Stories: IDOL TO ICON
What stands out is the tenderness in her reflections. She laughed at her nervous mannerisms, admitted how scared she was and shared details most fans had never heard before. The moment was not staged; it felt like someone flipping through an old scrapbook, grateful for how far they had come. Viewers loved the vulnerability with one writing “Seeing her watch herself was more emotional than the audition itself.”
Carrie Underwood’s story is proof that Idol is not just about finding stars, it is about shaping people. From a hopeful with shaky hands to a superstar and now mentor, her path shows the full arc of growth. Follow Carrie Underwood on Facebook, Instagram and YouTube to stay close to the journey she continues to share.